|

Introduction
The purpose of the project was to (a) identify and analyze
the effective components of successful substance abuse treatment
and vocational rehabilitation (VR) programs, (b) identify
areas of social-cognitive dissonance between VR counselors
and their clients that serve as obstacles to successful rehabilitation,
and (c) examine the use of effective, culturally relevant
treatment modalities different from those used in mainstream
treatment programs.
|
Methodology
In 1993
a VR counselor survey was conducted to identify exemplary
treatment centers for American Indians with alcoholism or
drug abuse disorders. A similar, but shorter follow-up survey
was conducted in 1996. Next, information was collected by
written questionnaire and focus groups from VR counselors
who work with American Indians with alcoholism or drug problems.
Information was also obtained from American Indian VR clients,
using both questionnaires and focus groups.
Results
1993 Treatment Center Survey. Most (18/31) of the treatment
centers were located on a reservation. Almost half (14/31)
were tribally operated; with (12/31) of the others operated
by the Indian Health Service. The top five treatment orientations
reported were: AA/Narcotics Anonymous (NA), generic outpatient
treatment programs, outpatient drug-free programs, 28- day
|
Hazelden
or Minnesota model inpatient treatment programs, and American
Indian traditional healing. The percentage of counselors who
were American Indian varied from 3% to 100%. Each center was
asked what percent of their American Indian/Alaska Native
client could be regarded as "successfully rehabilitated."
Responses ranged from 1% to 95%, with an average of 45%. The
highest success rate for an orientation was 76%, for the Native
American Church; however, only one program had this orientation.
Other treatment orientations claimed success rates averaging
from 41.3% for the outpatient drug-free program (n = 17) to
48.4% for the Hazelden/Minnesota Model (n = 18). The average
success rate claimed by American Indian traditional healing
programs (n = 15) was 45%. 1996 Treatment Center Survey. Fourteen
treatment centers, representing nine states, responded to
the survey. Half of the treatment centers indicated that "most
of " their treatment methodology was based on AA. The rest
indicated that "some" of their treatment methodology was based
on AA.

|